home/products/5 best toilet seats – round, elongated & soft-close

Product Review

5 Best Toilet Seats – Round, Elongated & Soft-Close

Architecture Lab may earn a small commission from qualified purchases via links on this page.
In brief

Toilet seats come in two shapes, round and elongated, and the bowl decides which one fits, so the measurement is taken from the bowl, not the old seat. Measured from the midpoint between the two bolt holes to the outside front edge of the rim, a round bowl runs about 16.5 inches and an elongated bowl about 18.5, and a seat made for one shape will not fit the other. Most bowls also share a 5.5-inch spacing between the bolt holes. After the shape comes the hinge. A slow-close hinge lowers the seat without a slam, and a quick-release hinge lets it lift off for cleaning. The Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch 4636-RL-0 does both on an elongated bowl and installs from above, and the Bemis Easy-Clean 500EC 000 brings heavy enameled wood to a round bowl, without a slow close. The Bath Royale Executive BR501-00 takes bolt holes spaced 4.5 to 6.5 inches apart, the TOTO SoftClose SS114#01 is a plain soft-close seat that stays steady on the bowl, and the Brondell LumaWarm L60-EW adds heat and a nightlight where an outlet is in reach.

5 Best Toilet Seats – Fit, Hinges & Heat

Toilet seats come in two shapes, round and elongated, and the bowl decides which one fits, so the measurement is taken from the bowl, not the old seat. Measured from the midpoint between the two bolt holes to the outside front edge of the rim, a round bowl runs about 16.5 inches and an elongated bowl about 18.5, and a seat made for one shape will not fit the other. Most bowls also share a 5.5-inch spacing between the bolt holes. After the shape comes the hinge. A slow-close hinge lowers the seat without a slam, and a quick-release hinge lets it lift off for cleaning. The Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch 4636-RL-0 does both on an elongated bowl and installs from above, and the Bemis Easy-Clean 500EC 000 brings heavy enameled wood to a round bowl, without a slow close. The Bath Royale Executive BR501-00 takes bolt holes spaced 4.5 to 6.5 inches apart, the TOTO SoftClose SS114#01 is a plain soft-close seat that stays steady on the bowl, and the Brondell LumaWarm L60-EW adds heat and a nightlight where an outlet is in reach.

SeatBest forBowlBolt spacingMaterialClosing
Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch 4636-RL-0Quiet close, lift-off cleaningElongated5.5 inPlasticQuiet-Close
Bemis Easy-Clean 500EC 000Enameled wood on a round bowlRound5.5 inEnameled woodStandard
Bath Royale Executive BR501-00Non-standard bolt holesElongated4.5 to 6.5 inPolypropyleneSlow close
TOTO SoftClose SS114#01A stable soft-close seatElongated5.5 inPolypropyleneSoftClose
Brondell LumaWarm L60-EWHeat and a nightlightElongated5.5 or 6.25 inPlasticGentle close

1. Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch 4636-RL-0 – Best Quiet-Close Seat for Elongated Bowls

The Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch 4636-RL-0 is the seat to buy for an elongated bowl. Quiet-Close action on both the seat and the lid prevents slamming, and the closing is quiet. With the ReadyLatch latches unlocked, the seat pulls straight up near the hinges for cleaning, and pressing the latches back until they snap onto the studs locks it in place again. It is a white, closed-front seat, well constructed, and Kohler says it fits most elongated toilets.

Installation happens entirely above the bowl, which helps on toilets whose bolt holes are hard to reach from underneath. The anchors fold flat to push into the holes and must open out completely once they are through, and the job is easy with Kohler's step-by-step instructions. Kohler spaces the mounting holes 5.5 inches apart. A seat that sits slightly off line is corrected by loosening the screws and rotating the seat mount, and Grip-Tight bumpers underneath keep it from shifting in use, so the seat fits well and stays where it is set.

Shape: Elongated | Material: Plastic | Bolt spacing: 5.5 in | Hinge: ReadyLatch with Quiet-Close | Fixing: From above | Standard cited: IAPMO/ANSI Z124.5

2. Bemis Easy-Clean 500EC 000 – Best Enameled Wood Seat for Round Bowls

The Bemis Easy-Clean 500EC 000 is the heavy, sturdy choice for a round bowl. It is enameled wood, which means wood flour mixed with resin, pressed into moulds and finished in high gloss, a formula Bemis calls more consistent than MDF, and the seat comes out heavier than the Bemis plastic seats. At 16.875 inches deep and 14.375 inches wide on a 5.5-inch bolt spread, it is sized for round bowls only, and it weighs 6.333 pounds.

The Easy-Clean & Change hinge lets the seat come off for cleaning and go back on, and the hinges and the two ring bumpers are colour-matched to the white. It fixes with non-corroding bolts and wing nuts, and the installation is easy. The seat does not close slowly, since Bemis titles it only for removal for cleaning. For a soft close on a round bowl in enameled wood, Bemis sells the 530SLOW Jamestown, titled with soft close and Never Loosens.

Shape: Round | Material: Enameled wood | Bolt spacing: 5.5 in | Size: 16.875 x 14.375 in | Weight: 6.333 lb | Hinge: Easy-Clean & Change | Hardware: Bolts and wing nuts

3. Bath Royale Executive BR501-00 – Best Seat for Non-Standard Bolt Spacing

The Bath Royale Executive BR501-00 is the seat for bolt holes that are not 5.5 inches apart. Its stainless steel mounting bases rotate to meet holes anywhere from 4.5 to 6.5 inches apart, and Bath Royale says the toilet's holes are not supposed to line up with the holes in the seat at all. The bases go onto the bowl first and the seat attaches afterwards, an easy installation, and the seat then lifts off the bases for cleaning. The quick release works properly only while the bases stay tight.

The seat is polypropylene, coloured all the way through so it will not chip, peel or fade, and Bath Royale makes the Executive one of its heavier, thicker and stiffer seats, for people who dislike a seat that flexes. The maker tests it to 400 pounds, and its sway test presses each side of the seat 26,000 times with 350 pounds. The slow close can be forced shut repeatedly without damage, and the two-year warranty covers that mechanism. Fitted with Bath Royale's taller bumpers, sold separately, it is compatible with most bidets.

A lifted seat can drop back down, and Bath Royale names two causes. New slow-close dampers are stiff and can make a raised seat spring back. On some toilets, a protruding tank or lid, or bolt holes close to the tank, stop the seat leaning back far enough to stay open.

Shape: Elongated | Material: Polypropylene | Bolt spacing: 4.5 to 6.5 in | Hinge: Quick release with slow close | Mounting bases: Stainless steel | Tested load: 400 lb | Warranty: 2 years

4. TOTO SoftClose SS114#01 – Best Plain Soft-Close Seat for Elongated Bowls

The TOTO SoftClose SS114#01 is a plain soft-close seat that stays put. Fitted in place of a wobbly seat, it sits steady on the bowl with none of the old side-to-side movement, and its SoftClose hinges lower both seat and lid. Colour-matched hinges fix it on noncorrosive nylon studs and nuts, which make the fitting easy. It is elongated polypropylene in TOTO's Cotton White, with a wide back, a rounded cover and bumpers moulded into the seat, about 18.5 by 14 inches on a 5.5-inch bolt spacing.

Shape: Elongated | Material: Polypropylene | Bolt spacing: 5.5 in | Size: about 18.5 x 14 in | Hinge: SoftClose | Hardware: Nylon stud and nut | Colour: Cotton White | Warranty: 1-year limited

5. Brondell LumaWarm L60-EW – Best Heated Toilet Seat with a Nightlight

The Brondell LumaWarm L60-EW is the heated seat, warm on cold nights and on trips to the bathroom in the middle of the night. It heats at three settings, 97, 100 and 104 degrees Fahrenheit, with an off position, and an LED nightlight runs on its own on/off switch. Both the seat and the lid close gently, and the seat is white and elongated.

The seat plugs into a standard GFCI wall outlet on a four-foot cord, which leaves from the left side when facing the toilet, so it needs an outlet within that reach. Without one near the toilet, the seat has gone back to the store or waited for an electrician to add an outlet. With the outlet in place the installation is easy, and Brondell puts a standard fit at as little as 20 minutes.

It fits elongated bowls measuring at least 18 inches from the bolt holes to the front. The bolt holes can be 5.5 or 6.25 inches apart, but there must be at least 1.25 inches between the bolt-hole centres and the tank. The seat measures 20 by 14.3 by 2.8 inches, and Brondell rules out seat risers.

Shape: Elongated | Material: Plastic | Bolt spacing: 5.5 or 6.25 in | Heat: 97, 100, 104 °F | Nightlight: LED with switch | Power: GFCI outlet, 4-ft cord | Size: 20 x 14.3 x 2.8 in

How to Choose a Toilet Seat

Toilet Seat Sizes: How to Measure for a Replacement

Plan view of a round and an elongated toilet bowl, each measured from the midpoint between the bolt holes to the front rim: 16.5 in (419 mm) for the round bowl and 18.5 in (470 mm) for the elongated bowl, with bolt holes 5.5 in (140 mm) apart
About 16.5 inches (419 mm) marks a round bowl and about 18.5 inches (470 mm) an elongated one, on a standard 5.5-inch (140 mm) bolt spacing.

Find the midpoint between the bolt holes, about 2.75 inches from each on the standard 5.5-inch spacing, and measure from there to the outside front edge of the rim. About 16.5 inches means a round bowl. About 18.5 means an elongated one, also sold as oval or oblong. Standard bowls run 14 to 14.25 inches across at the widest point.

Replacement Seats for Kohler, TOTO and American Standard Toilets

Kohler says its elongated seats fit most elongated one- and two-piece toilets and are not compatible with round bowls. It advises checking the product specifications for an exact fit. Its seat chart points to KOHLER.com/seatfit for a list matching each Kohler toilet to its seats. Kohler sizes the seat rather than the bowl, measuring from the hinge to the front of the seat. Its elongated seats run 18 5/8 inches or more, and its round-front seats 16 3/4 inches or less. Its seats come in ten colours matched to Kohler toilets. Some Kohler one-piece toilets receive the seat bolt in an anchor that takes a 1/4-20 bolt. On those, Quiet-Close seats tighten from the top into the anchors without the wing nuts. Kohler's wood seats, apart from the Q2 and Triko styles, need hardware kit 1104015 instead.

TOTO works to the same 18.5- and 16.5-inch bowl lengths, and its WASHLET needs mounting holes about 5.5 inches apart. Its range adds a third shape, though, since some TOTO SoftClose seats are D-shaped. TOTO says its SS124 SoftClose seat fits any toilet and is designed for WASHLET+ toilets, but the bowl shape still has to match. TOTO's skirted toilets ship with their own top-mounting hardware set, THU651N. The set is not included with the seats.

American Standard says its Champion Slow-Close seat fits most elongated toilets, and its Cadet 3 Slow-Close most conventional elongated toilets, with quick-release hinges and hardware included. Its VorMax toilets with CleanCurve rims have a seat made specifically for them. Bemis, for its part, designs its seats to fit most manufacturers' round or elongated bowls, though some specialty sizes exist. For a bowl that needs fine adjustment, it offers seats with Precision Seat Fit.

Wood or Plastic Toilet Seat: Which Is Better?

In the Bemis range, enameled wood makes the heavier seat and plastic the lighter one. Enameled, or moulded, wood is wood flour and resin pressed into a mould and painted to a high gloss. It makes a strong, heavy seat, though harsh cleaners can rub the finish off. Polypropylene, also called thermoplast, is lighter, flexible and resistant to breaking. It feels softer and warmer than painted wood but scratches more easily. Bath Royale colours its polypropylene all the way through, and the colour cannot chip or peel. Duroplast is a thermoset mix of urea and plastic granulate that resists scratches and heat, and it cannot be reshaped by heat once hardened. A padded seat adds a cushioned layer over a durable core, under a vinyl cover.

Toilet Seat Hinges: Slow Close and Quick Release

A slow-close hinge lowers the ring and cover gently to the bowl, and on a Bemis Whisper-Close seat a light tap starts it. Some take more abuse than others. Forcing a Centoco Safety Close seat shut can damage its hinges, and the seat usually closes in under 30 seconds. Bath Royale, by contrast, says the Executive can be force-closed repeatedly without damage, though its closing speed is fixed. A slow close that has stopped working is one of the signs a seat needs replacing. A quick-release hinge lets the seat lift off for cleaning, and Bath Royale's works properly only on tight bases.

Hinge materials vary from maker to maker. Bemis offers metal hinges in finishes that coordinate with other bathroom fittings, and its 1900SS commercial seat uses corrosion-resistant 300-series stainless steel posts. The TOTO SS114 uses noncorrosive nylon studs and nuts. Makers part ways on worn hinges. Hinges on Bemis plastic seats cannot be replaced, and neither can separate hinges on its enameled wood seats, because removing the screws can strip the holes. Kohler, by contrast, sells a hinge kit for select seats.

Toilets with Hidden Fixings: Top-Fix and Bottom-Fix Seats

Two cut-away sections through a toilet seat hinge: on the left a bolt held by a wing nut under the porcelain, on the right an expanding anchor inside the bolt hole tightened from above with a screwdriver
Where the bolt holes cannot be reached from underneath, top-fix hardware anchors in the hole and tightens from above.

Bottom-fix hinges fasten with nuts under the porcelain, and top-fix hinges install from the top of the bowl. Top fixing matters on toilets whose bolt holes cannot be reached from underneath, including those with a concealed trapway. The Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch installs from above as standard, Brondell sells top-mount kits for the LumaWarm, and Bath Royale sells top-mount anchors separately. Its split wing nuts hold themselves in place, with a large wing bearing against the side of most bowls, and the screw tightens from the top. Kohler's Quick-Attach hardware sits between the two systems. A wing nut goes on from below to catch the bolt, and a screwdriver then tightens the seat from the top, with no one holding the nut.

How to Tighten a Toilet Seat That Keeps Coming Loose

Seats work loose from being raised and lowered day after day. Bemis's STAY-TITE nut has a lower section that snaps off at the correct tightness, and a seat may loosen over time if that section is never snapped off. Centoco's Fast-N-Lock fastener slips and spins once it reaches a preset torque. Ordinary wing nuts need more care, because overtightening can strip or break the bolt. A seat that still wiggles after tightening may need washers on the nut against the underside of the toilet. Slight side-to-side movement is normal and acceptable, and Bath Royale sets a limit of a quarter inch on its polypropylene seats under a seated person.

A Bath Royale seat that has been loose for some time usually has urine or cleaner trapped under its mounting bases, and the residue makes them slip. The mounting surface then needs to be flat, clean and dry before the seat goes back on. Grippy bumpers, such as the Bemis Super Grip design, hold a seat against the bowl and stop it shifting. A seat that needs tightening again and again is due for replacement.

Taking off the old seat

Rusted bolts get a spray of rust penetrant or penetrating oil and a wait of five to ten minutes before the next try. Tools can easily chip the porcelain as the old seat comes off. Most Bemis seats install with a 5/8-inch or 1/2-inch socket or combination wrench, depending on the hinge. Before the new seat goes on, Bath Royale recommends glass cleaner around the holes to leave the surface clean and free of chemical residue.

When the seat or lid will not stay up

A tank cover set too far towards the bowl can push the lid forward. On some toilets the tank or lid protrudes, or the bolt holes sit close to the tank, and the seat then cannot lean back far enough. An adjustable seat can be moved forward on the bowl to give it room. A brand-new Bath Royale Executive that springs back may have stiff dampers.

How to Clean a Toilet Seat Without Damaging It

A soft cloth with mild dishwashing liquid diluted in water, or a gentle cleaner, is the cleaning Bath Royale and Brondell recommend. Bleach, vinegar, chlorine, acids, scouring powders, detergents, disinfectants and aerosols are all ruled out on Bemis seats. Keep toilet bowl cleaner off the seat, because it can stain, fade or scratch a seat permanently. Chemicals left on the LumaWarm for extended periods also damage its finish. On the Bath Royale Executive, spraying or soaking the hinges and bases can make the seat slide out of position.

Best Corner Toilets for Small Bathrooms

Best Wall-Mounted Toilets

Best Kohler Toilets for Modern Bathrooms

Kohler vs American Standard Toilets

Best Bidet Converter Kits

Niagara Stealth Toilet Review

Are toilet seats easy to install?

Toilet seats are easy to install, and all five here go on without difficulty. Most Bemis seats install with a 5/8-inch or 1/2-inch wrench, and the Kohler Cachet ReadyLatch installs entirely from above the bowl. Brondell puts a standard LumaWarm installation at as little as 20 minutes, and the seat needs a GFCI outlet within reach of its cord.

How do I know if I need a round or elongated toilet seat?

You need a round or an elongated toilet seat according to the bowl's length, measured from the midpoint between the bolt holes to the outside front edge of the rim. About 16.5 inches calls for a round seat, and about 18.5 inches for an elongated one. An elongated seat will not fit a round bowl, and a round seat will not fit an elongated bowl.

Are toilet seats universal?

Toilet seats are not universal, even though bolt holes sit a standard 5.5 inches apart and bowl lengths cluster at two sizes. Bemis designs its seats to fit most manufacturers' round or elongated bowls. Shape still decides the fit. An elongated seat will not fit a round bowl, some TOTO bowls take a D-shaped seat, and American Standard's CleanCurve rims have a seat of their own.

What is a bidet toilet seat?

A bidet toilet seat replaces the existing toilet seat and adds washing. TOTO's WASHLET fits most North American toilets. It draws water from the toilet's own supply through a T-connector at the base, and it needs a ground-fault 120-volt outlet within three feet. Kohler's manual bidet seats need no outlet at all. Its electric models need dedicated GFCI power. Bemis warns that a one-piece toilet with a deep French curve is likely not compatible with its bidet seats.

What is the best toilet seat for heavy people?

The best toilet seat for heavy people among these five is the Bath Royale Executive. Its maker tests it to 400 pounds, and the sway test presses each side of the seat 26,000 times with 350 pounds. Bath Royale also builds it heavier, thicker and stiffer for people who dislike a seat that flexes.

Can I use disinfecting wipes on a toilet seat?

Disinfecting wipes should not be used on a Bemis toilet seat, because Bemis rules out disinfectants, bleach, chlorine and aerosols. Toilet bowl cleaners can also stain, fade or scratch a seat permanently. Chemicals left on the Brondell LumaWarm for extended periods also damage its finish. For routine cleaning, Bath Royale recommends a soft cloth with mild dishwashing liquid diluted in water.

Is Mayfair the same as Bemis, and how does it compare with Kohler?

Mayfair is a Bemis brand, one of the Bemis family of toilet-seat brands. It sells enameled wood models such as the Cassel 1847SLOW, with Never Loosens hardware, removal for cleaning, slow close and adjustability. Kohler's Cachet ReadyLatch is plastic, with a lift-off ReadyLatch hinge, Quiet-Close and fixing from the top of the bowl.

What height should a toilet seat be?

A toilet seat should be 17 to 19 inches above the floor in covered public and commercial buildings, under section 604.4 of the 2010 ADA Standards. The same section bars seats sprung to return to a lifted position. Those Standards apply to new or altered government facilities, public accommodations and commercial facilities, not private homes, and local adoption decides which edition governs. For extra height at home, Bemis sells the Assurance as a 3-inch raised elongated seat. Brondell rules out risers under the LumaWarm, and Bath Royale under its seats.

What is the most comfortable toilet seat?

The most comfortable toilet seat for softness is a padded one, and Bemis builds its soft seats with a cushioned layer over a durable core under vinyl. Among hard seats, Bath Royale finds polypropylene softer and warmer to the touch than painted wood and recommends its stiffer Executive to people who dislike flex. For warmth itself, the Brondell LumaWarm heats the seat at three settings.

Why is my toilet seat turning blue?

A toilet seat turning blue or grey can come from a reaction with the skin, Bemis says, and switching to a plastic seat may prevent it in some cases. The Bath Royale Executive and the TOTO SS114 are both polypropylene.


Resources

  • Bemis Manufacturing — How to Measure a Toilet Seat; How to Tighten a Toilet Seat; What Material Should You Choose for Your Toilet Seat (consumer guides)
  • Bemis Manufacturing — Toilet Seat FAQs (fit, hinges, cleaning and loosening)
  • Bemis Manufacturing — 500EC Specification Sheet; Bidet Toilet Bowl Compatibility Guide
  • Kohler Co. — Toilet Seat Buying Guide; Toilet Seat Chart
  • Kohler Co. — Cachet ReadyLatch K-4636-RL Specification Sheet and Installation Guide
  • Kohler Co. — Wood Toilet Seats and Anchor Toilet Compatibility; Quick-Attach Hardware Installation (support articles)
  • TOTO USA — SoftClose SS113/SS114 Specification Sheet; SoftClose Seat Parts Manual
  • TOTO USA — Will a WASHLET Fit a Non-TOTO Toilet?; How to Install a WASHLET (installation guides)
  • American Standard — Champion and Cadet 3 Slow-Close Toilet Seat specifications
  • Bath Royale — How to Choose a Toilet Seat; Toilet Seat Installation; Troubleshooting; Executive BR-500/501 Installation Instructions
  • Brondell — LumaWarm L60 Specification Sheet; LumaWarm Heated Seat FAQs
  • Centoco — Toilet Seat FAQs
  • U.S. Department of Justice — 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design (section 604.4, water closets)
  • Architecture Lab — Best Kohler Toilets; Kohler vs. American Standard; Bidet Converter Kit Guide; Best Corner Toilets; Best Wall-Mounted Toilets

Article by Aline Chahine for Architecture Lab · Published 22 March 2023 · Updated 31 October 2026

More Product Reviews

All Products

Partners