107 Niddrie Road, Glasgow / John Gilbert Architects. Internal insulation preserved the sandstone street frontage; the rear and gable received external insulation. Photography: Tom Manley / John Gilbert Architects, via Passive House Plus.
Europe’s older homes need to become easier to heat. The work is changing facades, exposing structural problems and raising a question that energy calculations cannot settle: what should a renovation preserve, and for whom?
At 107 Niddrie Road in Glasgow, keeping the sandstone facade meant changing the way the floors met the walls. John Gilbert Architects wanted to insulate the four-storey tenement, built around 1900 and containing eight flats, without covering its street frontage. Their consultants’ moisture modelling identified a problem: timber embedded in the wall would become vulnerable after insulation was added inside. The design replaced that support arrangement with a perimeter beam, leaving room for insulation behind it. A decision about the appearance of the street had reached into the building’s structure.
Insulating historic housing involves choices like this at every scale. An exterior layer preserves floor space but changes the depth of a window. Insulation inside preserves the public face while disturbing the rooms behind it. Lower energy demand may reduce a building’s running costs, but the renovation’s financing determines how much of that benefit reaches its occupants.
The need for warmer homes is urgent. Eurostat reports that 8.8 percent of the EU population could not afford to keep their homes adequately warm in 2025. That figure covers the population as a whole, rather than residents of historic buildings alone. It is a reminder of what preserving a building unchanged can mean for someone living in it.
In Glasgow, Copenhagen and Bordeaux, architects have approached that problem in different ways. One project kept a sandstone frontage by rebuilding behind it. Another retained its brick walls but delivered smaller energy savings than expected. A third changed the face of a housing estate while keeping residents in their homes. Each offers a way to judge renovation beyond the appearance of the finished facade.
What the window gives away: external insulation
A facade is more than its visible finish. Its character depends on the distance between glass and masonry, the projection of a sill, the shadow beneath a cornice and the way a wall reaches the roof. Those relationships are easy to overlook in a specification organized by square meters of insulation. They become difficult to ignore when the new surface reaches an old window.
Historic England’s guidance describes the consequences. External insulation deepens openings unless the windows move outward. Sills need to shed water beyond a thicker wall; eaves and downpipes may need alteration. Insulation must continue around junctions where possible, because an untreated strip offers heat an easier route outside. A matching color does not restore the original geometry.
At Niddrie Road, the architects kept the stone exposed even though the tenement stood outside a conservation area. They used 120 millimeters of internal wood fibre at the front and 200 millimeters of external mineral wool at the rear and partly obscured gable.
Farther south, two housing blocks in Choisy-le-Roi, outside Paris, show another approach. Built in 1932, the Alphonse Brault and Paul Carle residences contain 208 homes. Contractor SPEBI records approximately 12,000 square meters of external insulation, including 6,000 square meters finished with a brick effect. Residents remained during the work, according to its project account.

The brick effect preserves a resemblance to the old facade. Whether it succeeds depends partly on the corners, openings and weathering of the new surface, and partly on what residents gained. SPEBI’s account documents the work and its intended appearance; it does not establish long-term energy performance or resident satisfaction.
Exterior cladding has a practical job in these assemblies: protecting what has been added to the wall. An insulating board with a rendered finish is not the same construction as cladding fixed over a drained cavity. The materials, supports and means of dealing with rain need to be understood together. Historic England emphasizes compatibility with the existing wall and warns against trapping moisture behind a protective exterior.
Internal insulation avoids many visible changes. It introduces losses that the street photograph will not record. Plaster cornices, skirtings and window linings may be disturbed or concealed. Radiators and sockets need repositioning. Insulation returning onto adjoining walls or ceilings affects the proportions of a room as well as its heat loss. In a small apartment, the thickness taken from the interior is usable space surrendered.
An interior can have as much to lose as an elevation. The repaired timber floors and retained joinery at Lisbon’s Avenida da Igreja apartment show the kinds of features a renovation can keep. Before choosing where to insulate, the survey needs to identify what is valuable inside as well as outside.
Internal insulation and the colder wall behind it
The Glasgow floor detail arose from a problem that is easy to miss: internal insulation makes the room easier to heat partly by reducing the heat reaching the original masonry. The masonry then operates under different temperature and moisture conditions.

A solid wall manages water through several routes. Rain enters, materials absorb moisture, and drying occurs as conditions allow. An internal layer changes that balance. Water vapor from the room may reach colder parts of the assembly; rain reaching the outside has to dry through a wall now receiving less indoor heat. The European RIBuild research programme starts its guidance with investigations of the existing building, including defects and sources of moisture, before considering internal insulation.
The word “breathable” is insufficient to resolve the problem. Vapor passing through a material is different from warm air leaking through a gap. An assembly needs appropriate drying capacity and control of unintended air movement. A compatible insulation product cannot compensate for a leaking gutter, a poorly sealed junction or a finish that changes the behavior of the layers beneath it.
Research commissioned by the UK government shows why thicker insulation needs careful assessment. The Demonstration of Energy Efficiency Potential programme, known as DEEP, combined investigations in 14 homes with laboratory work and modelling. Its modelling of wood-fibre internal insulation found a 20 percent reduction in space-heating demand at a wall U-value of 0.8 W/m²K, compared with 30 percent at 0.3 W/m²K. The less heavily insulated option retained roughly two-thirds of the saving, with lower modelled moisture risk. A U-value measures heat passing through a building element; lower values indicate less heat transmission.
The authors called for long-term field evidence before recommending a general threshold. Their result is a reason to examine the trade-off, not a universal specification. Weather exposure, materials and the continuity of the installation change the outcome. The same report explains that a whole-house approach concerns the interactions and risks created by the work, rather than simply the number of improvements installed.
These risks often sit at the edges of the drawing: where a wall meets a floor, a roof or a window frame. At Hackney House by Architecture for London, for example, internal wood-fibre insulation is paired with aerogel at the window reveals. The junction needs its own solution because the space available and the construction change there.
The owners’ meeting
Even a well-resolved section leaves another question unanswered: who can authorize it?
Niddrie Road offered unusual conditions. Southside Housing Association owned all eight flats, and they were empty before construction. The evaluation by the UK Collaborative Centre for Housing Evidence and its university partners identifies that starting point as a significant advantage. Work could proceed across the building without negotiating separate ownerships or undertaking the most disruptive operations around people living in each flat.
Paris faces a different scale of collective decision-making. The city describes approximately 47,000 copropriétés—buildings organized under shared ownership—representing three-quarters of its housing. More than 90 percent predate France’s first thermal regulations in 1974. Its Éco-rénovons Paris+ programme provides assistance through diagnosis, design, financing and construction, rather than treating an energy assessment as the end of the advisory work.
Adèle Arnoux, an adviser working in the 14th arrondissement, described the range of motivations in a published interview with the Agence Parisienne du Climat. Some owners approach renovation through environmental concerns, others through the preservation of their property, regulatory requirements, charges or discomfort. She noted that a building dominated by landlords approaches the subject differently from other ownership groups. Her work involves listening and communication as much as explaining technical measures.
The agency’s guidance for owners’ meetings makes the process concrete. A technical diagnosis establishes the building’s condition and compares costed scenarios. The owners then have to commission the design work that develops a chosen approach. Financial information and the explanation of alternatives arrive before the construction vote, not as corrections to it afterward.
For owners to judge the proposal, the drawings need to explain which details will change. The financial plan needs to separate necessary repair from additional energy work and show the contribution each household would make. A predicted saving means little to someone who cannot establish what the work will cost them.
Regulation supplies a timetable, though it does not choose the wall assembly. In metropolitan France, G-rated homes became ineligible for rental under leases signed, renewed or tacitly renewed from January 2025. The published schedule extends to F-rated homes in 2028 and E-rated homes in 2034. The rule did not abruptly terminate every existing G-rated tenancy on the first day of 2025.
At European level, the revised Energy Performance of Buildings Directive generally requires national trajectories reducing average residential primary energy use by at least 16 percent by 2030 and 20–22 percent by 2035, relative to 2020. Article 9 allows an adjusted trajectory for countries where fossil fuels account for less than 15 percent of residential energy use. These are targets for housing stock; they do not prescribe the same intervention for every dwelling.
Even along a single historic street, buildings can differ in ownership, wall construction and heating system. Meeting the national target will require separate surveys, agreements and construction work behind otherwise similar frontages.
Who receives the saving?
Swedish housing research raises a complication that a new energy certificate cannot reveal. Heating there is generally included in the rent. A reduction in the building’s energy use does not necessarily arrive as a separate saving in the tenant’s account.
Jenny von Platten and her colleagues Mikael Mangold, Tim Johansson and Kristina Mjörnell studied multifamily renovations undertaken between 2013 and 2019. They found that energy improvements within lighter renovations were associated with relative cost relief for tenants. Extensive renovations were associated with larger rent increases, and those projects disproportionately affected lower-income households.
Larger renovations bundled energy measures with other upgrades, and the dataset could not identify every individual intervention. The association was therefore with the renovation package, not a demonstrated effect of insulation alone. Within that rental system, a home requiring less energy could still cost its tenant more each month.
Rent, charges and the cost of any temporary accommodation therefore belong alongside energy consumption in an evaluation. Without them, it is impossible to tell whether a more efficient building has become a more affordable home.
Copenhagen provides another reason to look beyond the headline saving. At Ryesgade 30, an apartment building dating to 1896, preserving the brick facade led to internal insulation, alongside upgraded windows, ventilation and roof work. The project included new rooftop apartments. Researchers Jørgen Rose and Kirsten Engelund Thomsen examined the renovation using measurements and calculations, making it possible to compare the intended result with the occupied building.

The HiBERatlas project record reports measured consumption for space heating and hot water falling from approximately 155 to 83 kilowatt-hours per square meter annually. The post-renovation figure was higher than predicted. Residents maintained temperatures of 22–23 ℃ (72–73 ℉), rather than the assumed 20 ℃ (68 ℉), while heat recovery in the ventilation systems was less efficient than expected. The floor-area figures should not be mistaken for an equivalent percentage reduction in the entire building’s total use, especially after the addition of rooftop homes.
The researchers describe a rebound effect: some potential energy savings were taken as increased comfort. That deserves careful interpretation. The higher temperature does not establish that residents were previously unable to heat their homes adequately. Nor should a shortfall attributable to ventilation performance disappear into a general explanation about behavior. The two findings point to different questions—one about how occupants use improved homes, the other about how equipment performs.
Post-occupancy monitoring can distinguish those causes. Recording room temperatures alongside consumption helps establish how much energy is providing additional comfort and where a system still needs adjustment.
The work behind the finish
Some differences between promised and actual performance arise much earlier, during installation.
In February 2025, Zak Ashraf told a parliamentary inquiry that he had spent 15 months dealing with problems caused by a poor solid-wall insulation installation at his mother’s home. He was her registered carer. The committee’s report described substantial damage and a house declared dangerous. A project intended to improve a home had become a prolonged effort to obtain a remedy.
“I am just shattered,” Ashraf told MPs. “I work full time.” He was trying to manage his job, care for his mother and navigate the organizations responsible for putting the work right.
At the same hearing, Damian Mercer, whose company removes failed insulation, offered an unusually direct description of his trade: “My business should not exist.” His criticism concerned the workmanship and remedy problems he encountered. It was testimony from a contractor handling failures, not a survey of every installation.
A later Public Accounts Committee report provided a defined estimate. Drawing on audits of a statistically representative sample of 758 homes, it reported major issues requiring correction in an estimated 98 percent of external wall insulation and 29 percent of internal wall insulation installed under ECO4 and the Great British Insulation Scheme before mid-January 2025. These figures apply to those schemes and that installation period, not all insulation in Britain.
The report distinguished performance defects and moisture risks from immediate health-and-safety defects. The latter were estimated at 6 percent for external and 2 percent for internal installations. The same inquiry examined the lack of independence where installers appointed assessors or coordinators responsible for checking the work; the department acknowledged insufficient separation between those roles.
Inspection has to happen while the work can still be checked. Where a retrofit uses exterior cladding solutions, the drawings need to show how the facing, cavity and insulation meet at windows, roofs and ground level. Installers need those details on site, and responsibility for approving or correcting the work must be clear before the finish conceals it.
The Glasgow project missed the airtightness required for EnerPHit certification. Architect Chris Morgan drew a practical lesson in his published account: “the airtightness layer across the whole building should be accessible at the same time.” Completed finishes make defects in that continuous layer harder to trace.

The university evaluation found encouraging early performance and positive resident feedback, while recording problems beyond the fabric. One occupant went without heating for about a week and a half after outdoor heat-pump pipes froze. Residents reported uncertainty about operating the new systems. The researchers presented the early results as provisional, with monitoring continuing.
After handover, residents still need someone who can explain a ventilation control or diagnose an unfamiliar heating fault. Niddrie Road’s early evaluation shows why that support belongs in the renovation budget and programme.
A facade with room to live in
At Grand Parc in Bordeaux, Anne Lacaton and Jean-Philippe Vassal worked with Frédéric Druot and Christophe Hutin to transform 530 homes in three postwar social-housing blocks. Completed in 2017, the project retained the main structures and added winter gardens and balconies. Extensions 3.8 meters deep on the selected facades provided usable space outside the former apartment walls.

The change was visible. Small openings gave way to large sliding glazed doors, connecting rooms to the additions. Beyond them, an outer layer of glass and corrugated polycarbonate enclosed the winter gardens. Thermal curtains and reflective solar curtains provided further control. The facade had acquired enough depth to occupy, rather than simply enough thickness to reduce heat loss.
Prefabrication and sequencing allowed residents to remain through the work. A Field Guide to Retrofits in Occupied Buildings records 12–16 days of work per apartment, rather than for the development as a whole. The Pritzker Prize’s account also records the architects’ commitment to maintaining rent stability.
Lacaton described the approach in a published statement: “Transformation is the opportunity of doing more and better with what is already existing.” The retained object included apartments and their structural organization, but the project’s concern extended to people’s ability to keep living there.
The room for extensions at Grand Parc gave its architects options unavailable on a tight sandstone street. They could retain the apartments and their occupants while making a much larger change to the elevation. The project’s value as a precedent lies in that decision, rather than in a facade system that other buildings could simply copy.
The added spaces require an account of summer as well as winter. Glazing admits heat, and an enclosure that is useful in cold weather needs shading and ventilation when conditions change. Historic England’s overheating guidance treats shutters, awnings, opening areas and night ventilation as parts of the same assessment. Internal insulation may reduce the room’s access to the temperature-buffering effect of the old masonry. The result depends on the building, its surroundings and how occupants operate it.
A retained shutter can help control summer heat. An opening window allows residents to manage light and air. Both need to work with the new insulation and glazing, and remain usable after the renovation.

In photographs of Grand Parc, curtains hang at different heights and plants line the glazed edges. Residents have furnished the extra rooms for themselves. The additions are already part of the daily life of the buildings.
A resident at Niddrie Road gave the university researchers a shorter assessment: “My house is comfortable and cheap to heat.”
Resources
- Passive House Plus – “Flat Earth” (Chris Morgan, 2025)
- Historic England – “External Wall Insulation” (2025)
- Historic England – “Internal Wall Insulation” (2025)
- Eurostat – “Living Conditions in Europe: 2026 Edition” (2026)
- UK Collaborative Centre for Housing Evidence – “Niddrie Road, Glasgow: Tenement Retrofit Evaluation” (Kenn Gibb and colleagues, 2023)
- SPEBI – “Ravalement de Façade et Isolation Thermique Extérieure avec Finition Aspect Brique à Choisy-le-Roi” (project account, accessed September 2026)
- RIBuild – “Guidelines for Determining Whether a Building Is Suitable for Internal Insulation” (accessed September 2026)
- Department for Energy Security and Net Zero – “DEEP Report 1: Synthesis—Demonstration of Energy Efficiency Potential” (David Glew and contributing research teams, 2024)
- Ville de Paris – “Éco-rénovons Paris+: Encore Plus d’Aides à la Rénovation pour les Copropriétés” (accessed September 2026)
- Agence Parisienne du Climat – “Entretien avec Adèle, Conseillère France Rénov’ du 14ᵉ Arrondissement” (2024)
- Agence Parisienne du Climat – “Travaux de Rénovation: Préparez l’Assemblée Générale pour Obtenir l’Adhésion des Copropriétaires” (2025)
- Service Public – “Les Passoires Thermiques les Moins Bien Isolées ne Peuvent Plus Être Mises en Location” (2025)
- European Union – Directive (EU) 2024/1275 on the Energy Performance of Buildings, Article 9 (2024)
- Energy Research & Social Science – “Energy Efficiency at What Cost? Unjust Burden-Sharing of Rent Increases in Extensive Energy Retrofitting Projects in Sweden” (Jenny von Platten, Mikael Mangold, Tim Johansson and Kristina Mjörnell, 2022)
- Heritage – “Comprehensive Energy Renovation of Two Danish Heritage Buildings within IEA SHC Task 59” (Jørgen Rose and Kirsten Engelund Thomsen, 2021)
- HiBERatlas – “Ryesgade 30 A-C” (project record, accessed September 2026)
- House of Commons Energy Security and Net Zero Committee – “Retrofitting Homes for Net Zero” (report and oral evidence, 2025)
- House of Commons Public Accounts Committee – “Faulty Energy Efficiency Installations” (2026)
- Lacaton & Vassal – “Transformation of 530 Dwellings, Block G, H, I” (with Frédéric Druot and Christophe Hutin, 2017)
- A Field Guide to Retrofits in Occupied Buildings – Grand Parc Bordeaux case study (2020; available from NAIMA Canada)
- The Pritzker Architecture Prize – “Anne Lacaton and Jean-Philippe Vassal” (2021)
- Historic England – “Overheating in Historic Buildings” (accessed September 2026)
